The space above, below, and around the infrastructure can be used for commercial parking facilities, to earn new revenues and to address congestion.

The World Bank’s Municipal Public-Private Framework Case Studies includes around 100 Project Summaries with examples of commercial value capture in various sectors and from countries around the world. Below is a list of projects and project summaries which use Parking as innovative sources of funding.

To find more see Municipal Public-Private Partnership Framework.

List of Projects: Parking

• Moncloa Transportation Exchanger, Madrid, Spain (1)
• Hong Kong Mass Transit Railway Corporation, Hong Kong SAR, China (2)
• Sheberghan City Bus Terminal, Sheberghan, Afghanistan (4)
• Modern Bus Terminal and Municipal Market, Danli, Honduras (5)
• Bus Terminal-cum-Commercial complex, Mohali, India (6)
• Amritsar Intercity Bus Terminal, Punjab, India (7)
• Bus Terminal and Commercial Complex, Dehradun, India (8)
• Pulkovo International Airport, St. Petersburg, Russia (11)
• Commercial and Landside Operations of I Gusti Ngurah Rai International Airport, Bali, Indonesia (12)
• Mandaluyong City Market, Manila, Philippines (38)
• Automated Multi-level Car Park, Connaught Place, New Delhi, India (44)
• Underground Parking and Commercial Services Center, San Borja, Peru (45)
• Parking Area under Rivera Navarette Avenue in San Isidro, Peru (46)
• Queen Elizabeth II Medical Center Car Parking Project, Western Australia, Australia (47)
• Challenging Case: Multi-level Car Parks in Thimphu City, Bhutan (48)
• Sports Hub, Singapore (51)
• Campin Coliseum (Movistar Arena), Bogota, Colombia (53)
• Akaretler Row Houses, Istanbul, Turkey (56)
• Elbphilharmonie, Hamburg, Germany (58)
• Durban Point Waterfront Development Project, Ethekwini, South Africa (71)
• Capitol Crossing, Washington, District of Colombia, United States (75)
• Downtown Renewal, Silver Spring, Maryland, United States (76)
• Mixed Use Development, Virginia Beach, Virginia, United States (78)
• Long Beach Civic Center Project, Long Beach, California, United States (79)
• Sustainable Housing Project in Turin, Italy (81)
• Majadahonda’s Puerta de Hierro Hospital, Madrid, Spain (95)

Housing can be built above or around the infrastructure to generate additional revenues and many infrastructure projects offer space and opportunity for residential property development, and there is often opportunity to include low-cost housing. 

The World Bank’s Municipal Public-Private Framework Case Studies includes around 100 Project Summaries with examples of commercial value capture in various sectors and from countries around the world. Below is a list of projects and project summaries which use Residential and Office Space as innovative sources of funding.

To find more see Municipal Public-Private Partnership Framework.

List of Projects: Residential and Office Space

• Hong Kong Mass Transit Railway Corporation, Hong Kong SAR, China (2)
• Bus Terminal and Commercial Complex, Dehradun, India (8)
• Automated Multi-level Car Park, Connaught Place, New Delhi, India (44)
• Düsseldorf Museum, Kunstpalast, Germany (55)
• Akaretler Row Houses, Istanbul, Turkey (56)
• Jal Mahal Palace in Jaipur, India (57)
• Elbphilharmonie, Hamburg, Germany (58)
• Durban Point Waterfront Development Project, Ethekwini, South Africa (71)
• Croydon Council Urban Regeneration Vehicle, London Borough of Croydon, United Kingdom (72)
• Redevelopment of Library and Fire Station, Washington, District of Colombia, United States (73)
• Fire Station Refurbishment, Chapel Hill, North Carolina, United States (74)
• Capitol Crossing, Washington, District of Colombia, United States (75)
• Downtown Renewal, Silver Spring, Maryland, United States (76)
• Mixed Use Development, Virginia Beach, Virginia, United States (78)
• Long Beach Civic Center Project, Long Beach, California, United States (79)
• Regent Park Affordable Housing Project, Toronto, Canada (80)
• Sustainable Housing Project in Turin, Italy (81)
• Slum Rehabilitation Scheme, Maharashtra, India (82)
• Dege Eco Village, Dar es Salaam, Tanzania (83)
• Mafra and Ericeira Business Factory, Portugal (87)
• James F. Oyster Bilingual Elementary School, Washington, District of Columbia, United States (88)
• The North Toronto Collegiate Institute (NTCI), Toronto, Canada (91)
• Kenyatta University Hostels, Kenya (92)

Naming Rights is a form of advertising whereby a corporation, person, or other entity purchases the right to name for example a facility, object or program and any project that might involve an iconic asset should consider monetizing naming rights. Any project that might involve an iconic asset should consider monetizing naming rights.

The World Bank’s Municipal Public-Private Framework Case Studies includes around 100 Project Summaries with examples of commercial value capture in various sectors and from countries around the world. Below is a list of projects and project summaries which use Name Rights as innovative sources of funding.

To find more see Municipal Public-Private Partnership Framework.

List of Projects: Name Rights

• Ricoh Coliseum at Exhibition Place, Toronto, Canada (52)
• The North Toronto Collegiate Institute (NTCI), Toronto, Canada (91)
• Station Naming Rights, Dubai (100)

The space in and around an infrastructure project can be used for advertising and marketing, to draw attention from consumers and increase consumption of their products or services. 

The World Bank’s Municipal Public-Private Framework Case Studies includes around 100 Project Summaries with examples of commercial value capture in various sectors and from countries around the world. Below is a list of projects and project summaries which use Advertising and Marketing as innovative sources of funding.

To find more see Municipal Public-Private Partnership Framework.

List of Projects: Advertising and Marketing

• Moncloa Transportation Exchanger, Madrid, Spain (1)
• Hong Kong Mass Transit Railway Corporation, Hong Kong SAR, China (2)
• Sheberghan City Bus Terminal, Sheberghan, Afghanistan (4)
• Modern Bus Terminal and Municipal Market, Danli, Honduras (5)
• Bus Terminal-cum-Commercial complex, Mohali, India (6)
• Amritsar Intercity Bus Terminal, Punjab, India (7)
• Bus Terminal and Commercial Complex, Dehradun, India (8)
• Urban Transport Services, Peja, Kosovo (9)
• Pulkovo International Airport, St. Petersburg, Russia (11)
• Commercial and Landside Operations of I Gusti Ngurah Rai International Airport, Bali, Indonesia (12)
• Free Public Wi-Fi and Interactive Kiosks Project, Kansas City, United States (33)
• Smart Poles and Streetlights, Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh, India (36)
• Mandaluyong City Market, Manila, Philippines (38)
• Rooftop Solar PV and Energy for Underserved Communities, Connecticut, United States (66)
• Stellar Ace, Singapore (99)

In a similar way that advertising and marketing leverages high footfall areas, naming rights can leverage city icons to connect with consumers. By offering naming rights to reputed brands, governments can monetize the iconic image of infrastructure assets and engage reputable brands to leverage value from naming rights for brand recall and positive brand association.

However, naming rights for city icons such as stations need guidelines that align naming rights with community values.

Advertising is a well-established business segment for operators of public transit stations, terminals, and airports. High footfall areas within public transit are perfect locations to promote a product, service, or cause and are effective customer touchpoints for brands. Communities in high-mobility cities often regard advertising in public transit stations as quick reflections of what is in the market. In considering potential revenues from advertising and marketing, governments can leverage high footfall public areas for use in advertising and marketing while keeping journeys comfortable for passengers and avoiding uncomfortable distractions from advertising and marketing activities.

Case Studies with examples of commercial value capture divided in by Category. Alternatively, view them by Country or Sector.  The World Bank’s Municipal Public-Private Framework Case Studies includes around 100 Project Summaries with examples of commercial value capture in various sectors and from countries around the world. To find more see Municipal Public-Private Partnership Framework.

• Advertising and Marketing
• Naming Rights
• Residential and Office Space
• Parking (above and/or below ground)
• Hospitality and Tourism
• Medical Services
• Education
• Logistics Facilities
• Vehicle Services
• Retail and Commercial Space
• Development Rights for Master Planned Space
• Repurposing or Adaptive Reuse of Assets
• Infrastructure Sharing
• Usage of Facilities (Off-hours/Off-seasons)
• Results Based Payments from Third Parties
• Cost Savings from Energy Use Reductions
• Betterment Levy and Other Contributions
• Urban Congestion Zone Charges
• E-Commerce Service
• By-product Commercialization
• Leveraging Regulatory Changes
• Leveraging Knowledge Generators
• Municipal PPP Case Studies by Country
• Municipal PPP Case Studies by Sector
• Leveraging Climate Opportunities

______________________________________________

Check the Guidelines applying Commercial Value Capture (CVC) in infrastructure projects Section Overview or check the Content Outline.

Leveraging Greenhouse Gas Emissions Reductions and Other Third-party Contributions

The World Bank’s Municipal Public-Private Framework Case Studies includes around 100 Project Summaries with examples of commercial value capture in various sectors and from countries around the world. Listed below are project summaries which are leveraging greenhouse gas emissions reductions and other third-party contributions.  To find more see Municipal Public-Private Partnership Framework.

List of Projects

• Integral Treatment of Wastewater and Bio-Solids, Municipality of Saltillo, Mexico (25)
• Mafra and Ericeira Business Factory, Portugal (87)

The World Bank’s Municipal Public-Private Framework Case Studies includes around 100 Project Summaries with examples of commercial value capture in various sectors and from countries around the world. Below is a list of projects and project summaries with commercial activities within the footprint of the infrastructure.  To find more see Municipal Public-Private Partnership Framework.

List of Projects

• Moncloa Transportation Exchanger, Madrid, Spain (1)
• Hong Kong Mass Transit Railway Corporation, Hong Kong SAR, China (2)
• Sheberghan City Bus Terminal, Sheberghan, Afghanistan (4)
• Modern Bus Terminal and Municipal Market, Danli, Honduras (5)
• Challenging Case: Bus Terminal-cum-Commercial Complex, Mohali, India (6)
• Challenging Case: Bus Terminal and Commercial Complex, Dehradun, India (8)
• Challenging Case: Urban Transport Services, Peja, Kosovo (9)
• Pulkovo International Airport, St. Petersburg, Russia (11)
• Commercial and Landside Operations of I Gusti Ngurah Rai International Airport, Bali, Indonesia (12)
• Challenging Case: Doraleh Container Terminal, Djibouti (14)
• Smart Poles and Streetlights, Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh, India (36)
• Mandaluyong City Market, Manila, Philippines (38)
• Pike Place Market, Seattle, United States (39)
• Challenging Case: Bocaue Public Market, Bocaue, Bulacan, Philippines (40)
• Slaughterhouse Redevelopment, Cagayan de Oro City, Philippines (41)
• Challenging Case: Automated Multi-level Car Park, Connaught Place, New Delhi, India (44)
• Parking Area under Rivera Navarette Avenue in San Isidro, Peru (46)
• Challenging Case: Queen Elizabeth II Medical Center Car Parking Project, Western Australia, Australia (47)
• Challenging Case: Multi-level Car Parks in Thimphu City, Bhutan (48)
• Administrative Center, Tlajomulco Municipality, Jalisco, Mexico (49)
• Ricoh Coliseum at Exhibition Place, Toronto, Canada (52)
• Campin Coliseum (Movistar Arena), Bogota, Colombia (53)
• Aquanova America, Saint-Dié-des-Vosges, France (54)
• Akaretler Row Houses, Istanbul, Turkey (56)
• Challenging Case: Jal Mahal Palace in Jaipur, India (57)
• Elbphilharmonie, Hamburg, Germany (58)
• Marine Sanctuary and Forest Preserve, Chumbe Island, Tanzania (60)
• Kruger National Park, South Africa (61)
• Jozini Tiger Lodge, Jozini Municipality of KwaZuluNatal, South Africa (62)
• Rooftop Solar PV and Energy for Underserved Communities, Connecticut, United States (66)
• Durban Point Waterfront Development Project, EThekwini, South Africa (71)
• Croydon Council Urban Regeneration Vehicle, London Borough of Croydon, United Kingdom (72)
• Redevelopment of Library and Fire Station, Washington, District of Colombia, United States (73)
• Capitol Crossing, Washington, District of Colombia, United States (75)
• Mixed Use Development, Virginia Beach, Virginia, United States (78)
• Challenging Case: Dege Eco Village, Dar es Salaam, Tanzania (83)
• James F. Oyster Bilingual Elementary School, Washington, District of Columbia, United States (88)
• The North Toronto Collegiate Institute (NTCI), Toronto, Canada (91)
• Majadahonda’s Puerta de Hierro Hospital, Madrid, Spain (95)

The World Bank’s Municipal Public-Private Framework Case Studies includes around 100 Project Summaries with examples of commercial value capture in various sectors and from countries around the world. Listed below are project summaries with Commercial Activities Outside of the Footprint of the Infrastructure.  To find more see Municipal Public-Private Partnership Framework.

List of Projects with Commercial Activities Outside of the Footprint of the Infrastructure

• Moncloa Transportation Exchanger, Madrid, Spain (1)
• Hong Kong Mass Transit Railway Corporation, Hong Kong SAR, China (2)
• Kalangala Integrated Infrastructure Programme, Bugala Island, Uganda (43)
• Challenging Case: Queen Elizabeth II Medical Center Car Parking Project, Western Australia, Australia (47)
• Challenging Case: Multi-level Car Parks in Thimphu City, Bhutan (48)
• Challenging Case: Slum Rehabilitation Scheme, Maharashtra, India (82)